NLWC News
The NLWC’s Lane – Reflections on STM
As the end of the Fall season approaches, we would like to take some time to reflect on Nantucket’s recent Special Town Meeting,
held on November 4th.
The Nantucket Land & Water Council has been engaged in Nantucket’s discussion about short-term rental (STR) policy and regulation for many years. As an organization, we have, at times, faced questions from residents about
the relevance of STRs to the NLWC’s mission.
The NLWC’s mission is to help
preserve the long-term health of Nantucket’s environment and community through the protection of our land and water resources.
Development impacts the environment.
This simple fact should come as no surprise.
Our actions on the land have a direct impact on the health of our waters. Nutrients like
nitrogen
and
phosphorus
from septic systems and fertilizers, along with other
contaminants
such as those found in stormwater runoff, don’t just disappear. They
travel through the soil and into our ponds, harbors, and drinking water.
The accelerated development, repurposing of properties, and intensity of use associated with
short-term rentals (STRs) as a business put increasing
pressure on the island’s infrastructure, reduce habitat and biodiversity, and endanger our water quality.
Of course, a community needs to change and develop and grow, but
the health of our environment
and the ability of a place to naturally support the people who live there
are directly related to the intensity and type of development
and growth that
we, as a community, choose to allow and encourage.
The NLWC has always made it clear that we are not opposed to all short-term rentals. We support the ability of island residents to short-term rent with reasonable restrictions.
We have, first and foremost,
sought to reduce the impact from investor-owned STRs, and reduce the intensity of use and development
from properties that are maximized solely for the use of short-term rentals
because of the cumulative environmental impacts that this type of use and development creates.
We were very disappointed by the November STM vote, which resulted in the full codification of short-term rentals across all residential zoning districts of the island. It is clear that much of the community was incredibly alarmed by the simple messaging provided by Article 1 proponents that asserted this was a matter of maintaining an important property right or losing that right.
Alternatively, we, as proponents of Article 2, attempted to communicate a more nuanced message that memorializing this right with reasonable restrictions would actually allow most residents to continue short-term renting in a meaningful way while helping to protect the future of our environment and community.
As the dust settles, and
our media expresses the reality of the inadequacy of our existing regulations ( https://nantucketcurrent.com/news/nantucket-banned-corporate-owned-short-term-rentals-a-loophole-is-allowing-them-to-continue
), there is
clearly more that needs to be done.
All
of our
policies and practices relative to
growth, development, and land and resource management, including STR regulations,
must be scrutinized for their impact on our shared natural resources
and adjusted where needed to protect the health of our environment and community.
It is easy to make the claim that STRs as an issue is not “in our lane” and to suggest that how we use and develop our properties are somehow separate from:
PFAS issues, contamination of our public water supply, nutrient pollution, and water conservation, but these are the exact concerns that
compel the NLWC to engage in community conversations about growth, development, land use, and STRs. We are the voice for Nantucket’s environment, working to safeguard the present health and future sustainability of the island.
This is our lane.
We thank all of our members and friends for your support, regardless of your position or vote at STM. We know that, despite differences in opinion, we all share a deep care for this special place and a desire to protect what makes it unique.
Together, we can shape policies that reflect both the needs of our community and the limits of our fragile island environment.
Your willingness to stay engaged—ask questions, share concerns, and offer ideas—continues to strengthen our efforts.
There is more work to do, and we look forward to doing that work with you.
